11-07-2004, 10:37 PM
I don't know why everyone always tries to make it look like whenever people take a step forward in something, they're becoming technological maniacs and are getting lazy. This "Polar Express" movie that's coming out is nowhere near lazy from what I've seen. In fact, the 3D is so good, that they could have just used real people, but they chose to go with 3D. When I'm watching a movie, I could care less for the actual method they took in putting it on, just as long as the final product is enjoyable, which a lot of the times, it is. That's why Shrek is such a popular movie (which for some reason, people like to disguise that fact with "overrated").
The only reason I prefer my games in actual 2D, is because when you do it in 3D, it doesn't look like the developers wanted it to look. You get a bunch of blocky models and clipping and stuff. If we came out with 3D games, that had the exact detail and look of a 2D SNES game, people would probably still be complaining, even if it looked more beautiful.
Now, I'm not exactly rooting for 3D, but I'm not rooting against it either. My art style of choice is 2D, but if you saw some of my 2D Animation show up in a movie, then trust me, you wouldn't be calling it an "animated masterpiece" .I understand why people would perfer the 2D sprites of a game like Secret of Mana, to the blocky models of Final Fantasy 7, but in the case of 3D movies, which seem to all have been done quite well... I don't see the problem.
The only reason I prefer my games in actual 2D, is because when you do it in 3D, it doesn't look like the developers wanted it to look. You get a bunch of blocky models and clipping and stuff. If we came out with 3D games, that had the exact detail and look of a 2D SNES game, people would probably still be complaining, even if it looked more beautiful.
Now, I'm not exactly rooting for 3D, but I'm not rooting against it either. My art style of choice is 2D, but if you saw some of my 2D Animation show up in a movie, then trust me, you wouldn't be calling it an "animated masterpiece" .I understand why people would perfer the 2D sprites of a game like Secret of Mana, to the blocky models of Final Fantasy 7, but in the case of 3D movies, which seem to all have been done quite well... I don't see the problem.