Quarma

[na_th_an]

I don't go ape nothing, but your critique was not constructive. You pointed the bad things out, but didn't tell him how you would improve them. You just said that you did it better. That's not constructiveness.

When something is bad done, you should say it is bad done. That's the only correct point in your post, and most times people don't have the guts to do that. The thing is that it wasn't needed to be that harsh. A negative review should encourage someone to improve, and I think that yours does the contrary. Basicly, as I understand it, you are like saying "you code like crap, spend your time in something better".

And there is a plus: you can't stand a bad critique and you have demonstrated it lots of time, if not go and review the VPlanet forum, so be gentle. You know how bad it feels when your hard work is taken down.

[Lachie Dazdarian]

I did not said he codes like crap. I actually don't know how he codes generally.

Again, you go with that necessity of "how to improve" advises s-h-i-t. I belive, it CAN'T be improved by my opinion. Only completely remade. So shoot me for thinking that.

I never had problems with bad critiques of my games in QBasic community. Only problem was with Pong Worz, and anyone with 2 cents in his brain can figure out that VPlanet review of PW is unprofessionally and badly done. The problem was in his monitor, not my game. Period.

[TheBigBasicQ]

Lachie, i too found you a bit harsh. Not everyone can stand such bashing =(. If you cant post something encouraging then atleast dont discourage people. You could've gotten across your views in a more subtle and gentler manner =P.